Pakistan’s Internet Slowdown: Government Denies Firewall Claims Amid Rising Concerns

Pakistan is currently facing a major internet slowdown, which has intensified over the past few weeks. This disruption has led to widespread frustration among users and businesses, sparking a significant debate about the underlying causes. 

The Pakistani government attributes the slowdown to a surge in the use of VPNs (virtual private networks), while activists and digital rights organizations suggest that the real issue may be a newly implemented firewall designed to control and monitor online activities. This article explores both sides of the debate and examines the broader implications of the internet crisis in Pakistan.

Blame on VPNs

According to Minister of State for Information Technology Shaza Fatima, the primary cause of the internet slowdown is the increased use of VPNs by a large segment of the population. VPNs, which are commonly used to secure internet connections and bypass regional restrictions, have reportedly placed an excessive load on the country’s internet infrastructure.

Fatima claims that this has led to slower connection speeds and connectivity issues for all users. She has emphasized that the government is actively working with internet service providers and telecommunications companies to address and resolve these issues as quickly as possible.

Cybersecurity Measures

In addition to addressing the immediate slowdown, the government is also focusing on long-term cybersecurity enhancements. Fatima has highlighted that Pakistan is undergoing a significant upgrade to its cyber defense systems in response to rising cyber threats. The government views these upgrades as essential for protecting national security and maintaining the integrity of digital communications. 

Despite these assurances, the timing of these upgrades has raised concerns among some observers about the potential for increased state control over the internet.

Suspected Firewall Implementation

Activists and digital rights advocates, including organizations like Bytes for All, have voiced strong concerns about the possibility of a new internet firewall being responsible for the slowdown. Shahzad Ahmad, the Director of Bytes for All, argues that the evidence points to a firewall designed to monitor and restrict online traffic. 

According to Ahmad, this measure is aimed at curbing political expression and controlling the flow of information, particularly in light of recent political unrest and government crackdowns on dissent.

Economic and Social Impact

The impact of the internet slowdown extends beyond just inconvenience; it has serious economic and social repercussions. The Pakistan Software Houses Association has warned that the prolonged disruption could cost the IT sector up to $300 million. Businesses are facing operational challenges due to erratic VPN performance and frequent internet outages. 

This disruption has led to concerns about a potential exodus of IT companies from Pakistan, which could have long-lasting effects on the country’s technology sector and economic stability.

Petition for Fundamental Rights

In response to the ongoing internet issues, activists have filed a petition with the Islamabad High Court, requesting that access to the internet be recognized as a fundamental right under Pakistan’s constitution. The petition highlights the importance of internet access for free expression, economic activities, and everyday communication.

If successful, this legal challenge could set a significant precedent for internet rights in Pakistan and potentially influence policy decisions regarding digital freedoms.

Public and Business Concerns

The public reaction to the internet slowdown has been one of widespread frustration and concern. Many users and business leaders argue that the government’s actions are not only harming individual freedoms but also jeopardizing economic opportunities. Farieha Aziz, co-founder of the non-profit organization Bolo Bhi, emphasizes that the crisis is not just a matter of civil liberties but also a critical issue affecting livelihoods and the economy. 

Business leaders are particularly vocal about the need for immediate action to restore reliable internet services and mitigate the damage to the IT sector.

Follow Wat-Not on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram