Aayush Pathak
In a concerning revelation, a recent report has found that British employment laws are “significantly weaker” compared to those in other major economies, such as France, Germany, Italy, and Spain. The analysis, conducted by the University of Cambridge for the Trades Union Congress (TUC), highlights the widening gap in worker protections between the UK and the 38 member nations of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).
Weaknesses in UK Employment Laws
The research reveals that the UK scores lower than the OECD average on various aspects of employment laws, including working hours, unfair dismissal, employee representation, and industrial action. The report argues that this gap has widened since the Conservative government took office in 2010, when the qualifying period for unfair dismissal was doubled to two years.
The study also highlights the differences in employment laws between the UK and other wealthy countries. For example, many nations have laws “specifying Sunday as the default day of weekly rest and a right to a premium [wage] for weekend working,” which are not present in British legislation.
Unions Call for Reforms
In response to the findings, unions are urging Sir Keir Starmer, the leader of the Labour Party, to take action and implement reforms to protect workers’ rights. The TUC is calling for measures such as cutting workers’ hours and making strikes easier, arguing that these changes are necessary to create a level playing field and prevent good employers from being undercut by bad ones.
Paul Nowak, the TUC’s general secretary, emphasized the importance of these reforms, stating, “It’s time to turn the page on the Conservatives’ era of low pay and low rights that has been terrible for growth, productivity and living standards.”
Incoming Employment Bill and Employer Concerns
The UK government is currently preparing the incoming Employment Bill, which is expected to award workers full rights from day one. While these proposals aim to boost workers’ rights, they have raised concerns among employers, who fear an increase in unfair dismissal complaints and a system that mirrors the strict labour laws in France and Germany.
Wall Street banks that have expanded in Paris since Brexit have been calling on the French government to make it easier to get rid of staff, with one City executive stating, “Even with the recent lay-offs, our bank couldn’t get rid of the absolute deadwood in Paris.” Similarly, British lawyer Matthew Devey, who heads Linklaters’ German employment practice in Frankfurt, noted that some clients have been surprised by the “quite a rigid employment law regime” in Germany.
Balancing Productivity and Worker Protections
Behind the scenes, chief executives and union bosses in Britain have been trying to influence the government’s workers’ rights reforms, many of which will go through a consultation process. The TUC argues that “happier and healthier workforces are more productive,” suggesting that strengthening worker protections can have positive economic outcomes.
Professor Simon Deakin, who conducted the study and serves as the director of the Centre for Business Research at Cambridge University, believes that Britain is an “international outlier when it comes to worker protections.” However, he also emphasizes the need to strike a balance between productivity and worker rights, stating that some labour law reforms may “enhance productivity and help to ensure that workers and firms share the benefits of productivity gains.”
As the debate over employment laws continues, it is clear that the UK government faces a challenging task in updating its legislation to align with international standards while addressing the concerns of both workers and employers. The incoming Employment Bill will be closely watched as a potential turning point in the country’s efforts to strengthen worker protections and promote a more equitable and productive labour market.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings